An ice cream shop on St. George Street in St. Augustine makes its own ice cream in a back room and scoops it for a line of tourists that runs out the door most summer evenings. In late August a storm knocks out power to the block for two days. The dipping cabinets, the walk-in freezer and the hardening cabinet full of the next week’s batches all warm up and have to be thrown out, and the shop stays closed while it remakes inventory. The owner assumes his property policy will pay for the lost product. It pays almost nothing, because the building was never damaged and the policy did not include spoilage or utility interruption.
Ice cream shops look simple to insure: a small retail space, a counter, a few freezers and a friendly line of customers. Most do qualify for an affordable business owner’s policy. But the product is perishable, the equipment runs around the clock in a hot climate, and shops that make their own ice cream carry exposures a scoop-only franchise does not. The policy has to be built around those details.
What a Typical Ice Cream Shop Policy Looks Like
Most ice cream, gelato, frozen yogurt and dessert shops are written on a business owner’s policy, which combines general liability, property and business income. General liability covers a customer who slips on a dripped cone or is hurt by a falling sign, and it includes products coverage for illness or allergic reactions caused by what you sell. Property covers your freezers, machines, furniture, inventory and the improvements you made to a leased space. Business income pays lost income while the shop is closed after a covered loss.
Because ice cream shops are generally considered low hazard, many standard carriers write them at a reasonable price. The details on the application still matter: whether you make ice cream on site, whether you cook, whether you sell wholesale, and whether you run a cart or truck at events.
Freezers, Spoilage and Power Outages
For an ice cream shop, the most likely large loss is not a fire. It is a freezer that stops working. A standard property policy covers sudden physical damage from causes like fire, wind or a burst pipe, but it does not cover a compressor that fails mechanically or a power outage that starts away from your building. Three coverages close that gap. Equipment breakdown pays to repair or replace freezers, batch freezers and soft-serve machines that fail mechanically or electrically, and it often includes the income you lose while they are down. Spoilage coverage pays for product that melts or is ruined when refrigeration fails. Utility service interruption extends coverage to outages caused by damage to the utility’s equipment, which is how most Florida outages happen after a storm.
Check the limits as well as the coverages. A spoilage limit set years ago may not cover a full walk-in and several dipping cabinets at today’s ingredient costs, especially at the start of the busy season. Some policies also require the outage to last a minimum number of hours before spoilage coverage applies. Our article on hurricane preparedness for Florida restaurants covers backup power and other steps that reduce these losses.
Making Your Own Ice Cream Changes the Risk
A shop that scoops ice cream made by a supplier is a retailer. A shop that makes its own ice cream, gelato or mix-ins in the back is also a small food manufacturer, and that changes both the permits and the insurance. Dairy-based products can carry bacterial contamination if pasteurization, sanitation or machine cleaning slips, and soft-serve machines in particular need careful cleaning to prevent contamination. A foodborne illness claim tied to a product you made falls squarely on your business. Permits differ depending on whether you make frozen desserts or only sell them, so confirm your requirements with the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services or the Division of Hotels and Restaurants, whichever regulates your operation.
Allergens are the other big products exposure. Nuts, peanuts, dairy, eggs, gluten and soy are all common in ice cream and toppings, and cross-contact through shared scoops, toppings bars and mixing equipment is easy. Clear labeling, separate scoops for allergen-free flavors and staff who know how to answer customers’ questions all help. Our article on what happens when a customer claims food poisoning explains how these claims unfold.
Selling Wholesale
Many successful shops start selling pints or tubs to restaurants, cafés and grocery stores. Once your product goes out under your own label, you take on product liability for it wherever it is sold and eaten, and your customers may ask to be named as additional insured or for a vendor’s endorsement. Tell your agent before you start selling wholesale, because the products limit and classification may need to change. Our article on product liability for private-label brands covers the exposure that comes with putting your name on a product.
Carts, Trucks, Catering and Events
Ice cream carts and trucks at festivals, weddings, corporate events and farmers markets are often a big part of the business. Each one moves the operation off your premises. Event organizers and venues usually ask for a certificate naming them as additional insured, a truck needs commercial auto coverage, and equipment and inventory on the truck may need coverage away from the shop. If employees drive their own cars to deliver catering orders or restock a cart, hired and non-owned auto coverage fills a gap personal auto policies leave. Our pages on food truck insurance and catering company insurance cover those operations.
Seasonal Staff and Workers’ Comp
Ice cream shops run on part-time and seasonal staff, often young workers in their first job, and the busy season can double the crew. Florida requires workers’ compensation for non-construction businesses with four or more employees, counting part-time and seasonal staff, so many shops cross the threshold every summer. The common injuries are slips on wet floors, cuts, strains from lifting tubs and wrist and shoulder strain from scooping hard ice cream all day. Our article on whether you need workers’ comp in Florida explains how the state counts employees, and for shops whose staff changes constantly, our article on pay-as-you-go workers’ comp explains how to avoid a large bill at audit.
Your Lease, Your Build-Out and the Rest of the Program
Ice cream shops often lease space in shopping centers, on tourist main streets and near beaches, and the lease usually sets liability limits, requires the landlord as additional insured and asks for a waiver of subrogation. The build-out, including counters, plumbing, electrical work for the freezers and finishes, is usually yours to insure, and the improvements limit should reflect what it would cost to replace. Our article on shopping centers with restaurant tenants explains what landlords look for.
Ice cream shops also handle cash and card payments, so crime coverage for employee theft and money is worth considering. Business income deserves attention in a seasonal business, because a closure in July costs far more than one in January, and the limit should be based on the busiest months. The usual Florida questions apply too: the windstorm deductible is a percentage of the property limit, and flood is never covered by the property policy.
What Ice Cream Shop Owners Should Confirm
-
Do you have equipment breakdown coverage for your freezers, batch freezers and soft-serve machines?
-
Are spoilage and utility service interruption included, at limits that match a full inventory?
-
Does your policy describe whether you make your own ice cream on site?
-
Do you sell wholesale, and does your products coverage reflect it?
-
Do you run a cart or truck, and is it covered for liability, auto and equipment?
-
Are your allergen and cleaning procedures written down and followed?
-
Do you have workers’ compensation for your busy-season crew?
-
Is business income sized for your busiest months?
-
Does your policy meet every requirement in your lease?
Ice Cream Shop Insurance With Prestige
Prestige Insurance Group insures ice cream, gelato, frozen yogurt and dessert shops, coffee shops and specialty food businesses throughout Florida. We quote shops with standard carriers on a business owner’s policy and with over 100 MGAs and specialty markets for shops that manufacture, sell wholesale or run trucks and event carts. For related coverage, see our articles on coffee shop insurance and our guide to restaurant insurance in Florida. Send us your current declarations page and your lease, and we will tell you whether your freezers and your product are really covered. Call the office nearest you. Se habla español.
Miami: 305-969-8776 Orlando: 407-993-2331
General information only, not legal advice. Policy forms, coverages, waiting periods, food permits and carrier appetite vary and change over time. Refer to your actual policy, lease and permits for the terms that apply to your business.
