The board of a church in Vero Beach votes to dismiss its youth director after a series of complaints from parents. The decision is made carefully, over several meetings, and the minutes reflect it. Six months later the former youth director sues the church and each board member individually, alleging wrongful termination and defamation. The church’s general liability policy denies the claim because no one was physically injured and no property was damaged. The board members, all volunteers, are left wondering whether their own savings are at risk.
That is the situation directors and officers liability insurance was designed for. Church boards make decisions every month that affect people’s livelihoods, finances and reputations, and those decisions can be challenged in court even when they were made in good faith.
What D&O Coverage Protects
Directors and officers liability covers claims alleging that the people who govern an organization made a wrongful decision or failed in their duties. For a church, that includes elders, deacons, trustees, board members, committee members and, in many policies, staff and volunteers acting on the church’s behalf. Most policies also protect the church itself as an entity.
The coverage pays for defense costs, settlements and judgments, subject to the policy’s terms. Defense costs are often the most valuable part. A claim without merit can still take months or years to resolve, and legal fees accumulate whether or not the board did anything wrong.
Why General Liability Does Not Respond
A church’s general liability policy is built around bodily injury, property damage and certain personal injury offenses. Most governance disputes involve none of those. A claim that the board mismanaged a building fund, breached a contract, discriminated in a hiring decision or improperly removed a member from leadership is a claim about decisions and money, not injuries. General liability policies typically exclude or simply do not address those claims, which is why a separate D&O policy, or a D&O coverage part within a church package, is needed.
Where Claims Against Church Boards Come From
Employment decisions are the most common source. Terminating a pastor, staff member or teacher, declining to hire someone, or handling a harassment complaint can all lead to claims of wrongful termination, discrimination or retaliation. Many church D&O policies include employment practices coverage or offer it as an option, and for a church with paid staff it is one of the most important pieces to confirm.
Financial decisions are another. Members may question how funds were spent, how a capital campaign was managed or whether a property sale was handled properly. Disputes over the use of restricted gifts, building projects that run over budget and conflicts with lenders can all lead to allegations against the board.
Governance and membership disputes round out the picture. Church splits, contested elections, disputes over bylaws and decisions to remove members can become legal disputes, particularly when property or assets are involved. Contract disputes with vendors and claims involving the church’s affiliated ministries, such as a school or community program, also land on the board.
What D&O Policies Typically Exclude
D&O policies are written on a claims-made basis, which means coverage generally applies to claims first made during the policy period, sometimes subject to a retroactive date. Letting a policy lapse, or switching carriers without confirming prior acts coverage, can leave a gap for decisions made in earlier years.
Most policies also exclude bodily injury and property damage, which belong under general liability, and intentional fraud or criminal acts once established. Claims involving sexual misconduct are normally handled under abuse and molestation coverage rather than D&O, which we cover in abuse and molestation coverage for Florida churches. Understanding where one coverage ends and another begins is what keeps a church from discovering a gap after a claim is filed.
Protecting Volunteer Board Members
Florida law provides certain protections for volunteer directors and officers of nonprofit organizations, but those protections have limits and do not prevent someone from filing a lawsuit in the first place. Even when a volunteer is ultimately found not liable, defending the case costs money. D&O coverage is often what makes it possible for capable people to agree to serve on a church board, because they know the church has arranged protection for the decisions they make on its behalf.
The church’s bylaws matter here too. Many bylaws include indemnification provisions promising to defend and reimburse board members. Those promises are only as good as the church’s ability to pay, and D&O insurance is what funds them.
Good Governance Reduces the Risk
Insurance responds after a claim. Sound practices reduce the chance of one. Churches that keep accurate minutes, follow their bylaws, document employment decisions, use written job descriptions and personnel policies, and seek legal advice on significant decisions tend to have fewer disputes and stronger defenses when disputes arise. Conflicts of interest should be disclosed and recorded, and financial controls should include more than one person reviewing how money moves. Our article on pastoral counseling liability covers another area where a church’s professional decisions create exposure.
Fitting D&O Into the Church Program
Some carriers that write church packages include D&O as a coverage part, while others place it separately. Limits, deductibles, employment practices coverage and the definition of who is insured vary from policy to policy, so it is worth reviewing the actual wording rather than relying on a line item that simply says D&O is included. Our church insurance page explains how D&O works alongside property, liability and the other coverages a church carries.
Worth Confirming With Your Agent
-
Whether your church carries D&O coverage, and whether it is part of a package or a separate policy
-
Who is defined as an insured, including board members, committee members, staff and volunteers
-
Whether employment practices claims are covered, and at what limit
-
The policy’s retroactive date and whether prior acts coverage carried over from earlier policies
-
Whether defense costs reduce the limit or are paid in addition to it
-
How the D&O policy coordinates with your abuse and molestation and general liability coverage
This article is general information and is not legal advice.
Talk to Prestige Insurance Group
Prestige Insurance Group works with churches across Florida to protect the people who lead them, from volunteer boards to pastoral staff. If your church is not sure whether its board is covered, or how its D&O policy would respond to an employment or governance claim, we can review the coverage with you and explain the options.
Call the office nearest you. Se habla español.
Orlando: 407-993-2331
Miami: 305-969-8776
Stuart: 772-247-3788
Prestige Insurance Group, License L057894
