A general contractor in Broward hires a framing crew through a sub he has used twice before. The certificate of insurance checks out — active workers’ compensation, a company registered with the state, a policy number that verifies.
Six weeks later a worker on that crew falls and breaks his hip. He does not know the name of the company on the certificate. He knows the name of his crew leader, and he was paid in cash.
The certificate was real. The company was real. The worker was not on its payroll, and neither were the other two hundred people working under that same policy across a dozen job sites.
How the Scheme Works
Karen Phillips, general counsel at FUBA Workers’ Comp, described this arrangement in Rough Notes — a fraud pattern that started in South Florida and has spread north through most of the state’s major markets.
The structure is straightforward once you see it. A facilitator arranges for someone to register a company with the Division of Corporations under a deliberately vague name — something with “Services” or “Construction” in it, or a set of initials. Vague matters, because the same entity will be used across unrelated trades and job sites.
That company buys a workers’ compensation policy and reports a modest amount of payroll in a construction class, usually one that uses unskilled labor and requires no license. Enough to look like a small operating business. Nothing that draws attention.
Then the certificate gets rented out. Dozens of crews, hundreds of workers, spread across job sites that have nothing to do with each other, all presenting the same proof of coverage. Payroll checks from general contractors go through check cashing outlets, the facilitator takes a cut, and what remains reaches the crew leader in cash.
The carrier issued a policy for a small framing operation. What it actually covered, on paper, was millions in payroll across multiple trades that it never knew existed and never collected premium on.
Who Absorbs the Loss
The injured worker is in the worst position. He does not know which company employs him or who insures it. He was paid in cash by a crew leader. When he needs medical care, there is no obvious path to it.
The general contractor is exposed in a way most do not anticipate. Under Florida law, a contractor is generally responsible for ensuring subcontractors carry workers’ compensation. A certificate from an entity that was not actually employing the injured worker may not satisfy that. The claim can land on the GC’s own policy — and the payroll paid to that subcontractor can be added to the GC’s payroll at audit, generating premium nobody budgeted.
Legitimate subcontractors lose work. A framing crew reporting real payroll and paying real premium cannot bid against one paying a fraction of it. This is the part that gets discussed least and matters most to the honest operators in the trade.
The carrier never receives the premium for the exposure it is carrying, and pays claims for people it did not know existed.
What These Operations Look Like
No single characteristic proves anything. Several together are the pattern. Phillips identifies the following markers:
The name is deliberately generic. Initials, or something with “Services” or “Construction” attached, without any indication of a specific trade. A company that does one thing usually says so.
The class code is unlicensed and unskilled. Framing, drywall, concrete, masonry, carpentry, painting. Trades that require no state license and can absorb large numbers of workers.
The business address is not a business. A post office box, a mailbox store, a small residence.
Payment comes in unusual form. A money order, or a starter check with the company name written by hand.
The agent is far from the work. A company operating in one region insuring through an agent several hours away, for no apparent reason.
Changes come quickly after binding. Requests to add or change class codes shortly after the policy is issued.
Audits go unanswered. This one is the clearest signal, because an operation with unreported payroll cannot survive an audit.
Certificate requests do not match the policy. A volume of certificates far beyond what the reported payroll would support, requests for vague descriptions of operations, or requests to list class codes the policy does not include.
What a General Contractor Can Actually Do
Verify coverage at the source, not on the paper. The Florida Division of Workers’ Compensation maintains a public Proof of Coverage database. Check the company there rather than relying on the certificate you were handed. Confirm the coverage is active, and look at whether prior policies were cancelled.
Confirm the entity matches the crew. The company on the certificate should be the company whose name appears on the checks, and the person you are dealing with should be an officer of it. If the crew leader cannot say who employs him, that is the answer.
Look at the address. A quick search of the business address takes thirty seconds.
Collect certificates before work starts and track expiration. A certificate collected in January says nothing about September, and mid-project cancellation is common in these arrangements.
Ask about payment structure. A subcontractor paying employees through a real payroll process, with state and federal unemployment taxes, is a different operation than one cashing checks.
Watch for a bid that does not make sense. A number well below what the labor alone should cost is usually explained by something, and this is one of the explanations.
If You Are a Legitimate Subcontractor
Two things are worth knowing.
You are the party losing bids to this, and documenting your own compliance is a competitive argument rather than a formality. Being able to produce current coverage, an accurate class code, and a clean audit history is a reason for a GC to use you over a cheaper number.
And if someone approaches you about registering a company, holding a policy, or lending your certificate in exchange for a fee, that is the recruitment stage of this scheme. The person whose name is on the entity is the one the state and the carrier will be looking for.
The Underlying Point
Certificates of insurance are the least reliable document in construction. They are a snapshot, they are easy to produce, and they say nothing about whether the entity named on them actually employs the people on your site.
Verification takes a few minutes. Absorbing an injured worker’s claim, plus the audit premium on a subcontractor’s unreported payroll, takes considerably longer.
Prestige Insurance Group works with contractors and subcontractors across Florida on workers’ compensation, general liability, and contractor coverage — including help building a subcontractor verification process that holds up at audit.
Miami 305-969-8776 · Orlando 407-993-2331 · Stuart 561-983-4333
Se Habla Español.
This article is general information and not legal advice. It draws on reporting by Karen Phillips, general counsel of FUBA Workers’ Comp, published in Rough Notes. Consult qualified counsel regarding your obligations, and report suspected insurance fraud to your carrier and to the Florida Division of Investigative and Forensic Services.
