Two contractors in Hialeah call for quotes the same day. Similar revenue, three employees each, five years in business.
One does interior finishes. The other does roofs.
The premiums look nothing alike, and it has almost nothing to do with the size of either business. In this class the trade drives the number more than anything else.
What the Premium Is Built From
Contractor insurance is not one figure. Each piece rates on a different basis.
General liability rates on gross receipts or payroll depending on the classification. Both are auditable, so reporting low to lower a quote does not save money — it produces a bill twelve months later.
Workers’ compensation rates on payroll. In Florida the rate for a class code is filed and approved by the state, so the rate itself is the same at every carrier. What changes is how your payroll is classified and what your experience modification factor is doing.
Tools and equipment rate on values.
Commercial auto rates on vehicles and drivers.
Four pieces, four bases. A quote built on wrong assumptions in any of them is not comparable to one built on accurate figures.
The Trade Moves It Most
The spread between trades is enormous and not proportional to how the work looks from outside.
Work at height, structural work, roofing, demolition, and anything involving heat or open flame rate far above interior finish, carpentry, painting, and handyman work.
What also matters is the mix. A remodeling contractor who does one roof a year does not price like one doing roofs every week — but he has to declare it. An undeclared trade that surfaces during a claim is a much larger problem than a higher premium would have been.
The Rest of What Drives It
Residential or commercial. Many programs treat them differently and some exclude one entirely.
New or established. A contractor under three years in business has fewer markets available, and that shows in the price.
Claims history, which carries several years back.
Territory. Miami-Dade and Broward rate differently from Central Florida.
The limits your contracts require. A general contractor demanding two million rather than one, plus an umbrella, has defined your program before you speak to an agent.
Whether you use subcontractors, and whether they are insured. That last one costs real money.
Uninsured Subcontractors Become Your Payroll
This is the largest unexpected cost in the class and the one most often missed when comparing quotes.
You are responsible for verifying that your subcontractors carry their own coverage. Where one does not, that payroll can be charged to your policy at audit — rated at the class code for the work the sub performed, not yours.
Sub out roofing to an uninsured crew and that payroll gets charged at the roofing rate, months after the job closed and was billed.
An exemption certificate does not solve it. An exemption covers the owner who filed it and nobody else on his crew. The question is whether anyone on that crew is covered.
Collecting the certificate before work starts is what prevents the bill, and it is the biggest single difference between two contractors who otherwise look identical.
Why a Cheaper Quote Is Usually Cheaper for a Reason
In this class quotes get cheaper through exclusions rather than efficiency. Five things to check before comparing prices.
Roofing or height exclusions. Many programs exclude work above a stated height, or exclude roofing entirely.
Independent contractors exclusion, which removes coverage for work performed by anyone who is not your employee.
Structural work exclusions, or exclusions on specific operations.
Products and completed operations. If excluded, claims arriving after the job is finished are not covered — and those are the ones that arrive late and cost most.
Additional insured and the exact wording your contracts require. Additional insured, primary and non-contributory, waiver of subrogation. Those come from endorsements, not certificates, and some carriers charge for them.
If one quote is materially cheaper and all five answers come back the same, it is genuinely cheaper. Usually at least one differs, and none of it appears in the premium.
What Actually Reduces It
Classify payroll correctly. If your crews do different work, that payroll should be split across the right codes rather than all landing in the most expensive one.
Keep subcontractor certificates current, which avoids the audit bill more than it lowers the quote.
Maintain a clean loss history, which compounds over years.
Claim the workers’ compensation credits for qualifying drug-free workplace and safety programs, which require actual compliance rather than a checkbox.
Report receipts and payroll accurately, which does not lower the premium and does prevent the year-end surprise.
What does not work is accepting exclusions to reach a number. That saves money now and moves the cost to the day of the claim.
What to Ask Before Comparing
-
What receipts or payroll figure is each quote rated on, and is it accurate?
-
Are all the trades you actually perform declared?
-
Is there a roofing, height, or structural exclusion?
-
Is there an independent contractors exclusion?
-
Is products and completed operations included?
-
Does each quote include the endorsements your contracts require?
-
Do you have current certificates from every subcontractor?
-
How is your payroll classified for workers’ compensation?
Contractor Insurance in Florida
Prestige Insurance Group writes contractors and artisan trades across Miami, Hialeah, Doral, Fort Lauderdale, West Palm Beach, Orlando, and Tampa, including trades that are difficult to place.
If you are comparing quotes, send us the one you have along with one of your contracts. In this class the difference between two quotes is in the exclusions and the endorsements, and that is visible in the forms rather than the price.
Call the office nearest you.
Miami: 305-969-8776 Orlando: 407-993-2331
General information only, not legal advice. Rating bases, coverage forms, exclusions, endorsements, and carrier appetite vary and change over time, and pricing depends on the specific operation. Florida workers’ compensation classification rules are subject to change; confirm current requirements with the Florida Division of Workers’ Compensation. Refer to your actual policies and quotes for the terms that apply to your business.
